Home » Valentine’s Day Cookies

Valentine’s Day Cookies

I don’t know when our family started the sweet tradition of making these cookies every Valentine’s Day, but I assume it was well before I was born. My Nana made them. My mother made them, too–actually, she still does–and now we all make them. I know that today and tomorrow my mom, aunts, sister, and cousins will be baking and decorating Valentine’s Day Cookies whether we’re here in Alabama, or in Florida, or Georgia, or wherever. I love that we’re all making the same thing we remember from childhood. (Although I notice that my Aunt Kali is an overachiever: her pretty cookies are already up on Facebook.)

These are simple but delicious butter cookies with a simple icing that hardens nicely. The dough is easy to handle and it rolls out well. Both the dough and icing are easy for children to work with. If you don’t have a heart-shaped cookie cutter, just cut out round cookies (or roll dough into a log to use slice-and-bake style) and paint hearts on them with the icing. I’m hopeless with a pastry bag for decorating, but I manage to decorate these with a butter knife and a spoon anyway. Some of my relatives are more coordinated.

My mother makes them all pink and pretty, but I do a range of colors from white to red because when my girls were little they couldn’t agree. The range of icing colors is easy to accomplish: just ice a few cookies with the plain white icing before adding any red food coloring, then add a few drops of red, ice a few more, add a little more food coloring, and ice a few more. I also like some cookies dipped in chocolate if I have any. Sprinkles or colored sugar are always welcome.

The original recipe in calls for ½ teaspoon vanilla and ½ teaspoon almond extract. I don’t think I’ve ever owned any almond extract, and I always substitute more vanilla extract instead. You should do whatever makes you and yours happy in the extract department.

As an added bonus, these butter cookies travel very well. Over the years we have delivered them to school for Valentine’s Day parties, plated them up and taken them to neighbors and friends, and even boxed them up and mailed them off to a child or grandchild in college. (That last one is my favorite. It went a long way toward ensuring my popularity with my dorm-mates.)

LOVE AND COOKIES!

Valentine's Day Cookies

Ingredients

  • 1/2 lb. butter, at room temperature
  • 2/3 cup sugar
  • 3 egg yolks
  • 2 T. cream, plus more for icing
  • 1/2 t. vanilla extract, plus more for icing
  • 1/2 t. almond extract
  • 2 1/2 cups flour
  • 1 cup powdered sugar
  • 2 T. cream
  • 1/2 t. vanilla extract

Instructions

  • Cream together butter and sugar. Add the egg yolks, 2 T. cream, extracts and flour. Make a stiff dough. Chill in the refrigerator. Roll thin and cut out, (The dough can be shaped into a roll, wrapped in wax paper, and sliced after chilling.) Bake on a cookie sheet in a 350° oven for 10-12 minutes. Cool.
    For the icing:
    Stir together powdered sugar, 2 T. cream, and 1/2 t. vanilla. If icing is too dry, add a little more cream. Add food coloring a drop or two at a time to color icing if you like. Spread thinly on cookies and allow to dry/set.
Newsletter Signup

Newsletter Signup

Sign up and be the first to receive our new recipes, class information and more! We promise not to share your information.

Instagram

Here's your new holiday side:  Stuffed Acorn Squash.

It's easy, delicious, and it travels well.

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/stuffed-acorn-squash/

#holidayfood #thanksgiving #southernfood
#foodstagram #southerncooking #familyfriendly
#easyrecipes #thanksgivingrecipes #stuffedvegetables #eatyourveggies #yum
Here's your new holiday side: Stuffed Acorn Squash. It's easy, delicious, and it travels well. Littlecoastalkitchen.com/stuffed-acorn-squash/ #holidayfood #thanksgiving #southernfood #foodstagram #southerncooking #familyfriendly #easyrecipes #thanksgivingrecipes #stuffedvegetables #eatyourveggies #yum
5 days ago
View on Instagram |
1/9
Yay!  Holiday party food is such a treat!  Today's installment is Cranberry Pecan Cheese Ball!

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/cranberry-pecan-cheese-ball/

#holidayfood #holidays #southerncooking #southernfood  #thanksgiving #partyfood #appetizers #cheese #cranberries #cranberry #pecans #familyfavorite #foodstagram #yum
Yay! Holiday party food is such a treat! Today's installment is Cranberry Pecan Cheese Ball! Littlecoastalkitchen.com/cranberry-pecan-cheese-ball/ #holidayfood #holidays #southerncooking #southernfood #thanksgiving #partyfood #appetizers #cheese #cranberries #cranberry #pecans #familyfavorite #foodstagram #yum
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
2/9
UPDATE:  Lazy Chef's Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen is full.  HOWEVER, if we can fill another class, I'll add one!  I need 8 attendees for the class to fill.  I'm looking at the calendar now---
UPDATE: Lazy Chef's Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen is full. HOWEVER, if we can fill another class, I'll add one! I need 8 attendees for the class to fill. I'm looking at the calendar now---
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
3/9
Join us for our annual Lazy Chef's Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen 2024! I'll be making brand new, easy, inexpensive gifts this year, no cooking skills required. Class is Saturday, Dec. 7th, 10am. Email me to register: malia@littlecoastalkitchen.com. Class is $40, and it's always fun!
Join us for our annual Lazy Chef's Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen 2024! I'll be making brand new, easy, inexpensive gifts this year, no cooking skills required. Class is Saturday, Dec. 7th, 10am. Email me to register: malia@littlecoastalkitchen.com. Class is $40, and it's always fun!
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
4/9
It's TexMex Tuesday,  y'all.  What are you having for dinner?  Weeknight Chicken Carnitas!

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/weeknight-chicken-carnitas/
It's TexMex Tuesday, y'all. What are you having for dinner? Weeknight Chicken Carnitas! Littlecoastalkitchen.com/weeknight-chicken-carnitas/
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
5/9
It's available!  My new cookbook, Soups and Sides, is up on Amazon, in both hardback and paperback.  Enjoy!

#cookbooks #christmaspresents #soup
#soupseason #familyfriendly #familyfriendly #homecooking #recipes #yum
It's available! My new cookbook, Soups and Sides, is up on Amazon, in both hardback and paperback. Enjoy! #cookbooks #christmaspresents #soup #soupseason #familyfriendly #familyfriendly #homecooking #recipes #yum
4 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
6/9
By request.  Deviled Eggs!

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/deviled-eggs/

#southerncooking #picnic #foodstagram #deviledeggs #familyfavorite #tailgatesnacks #tailgate #lowcarb #easyrecipes #easypartyfood #coastalliving
By request. Deviled Eggs! Littlecoastalkitchen.com/deviled-eggs/ #southerncooking #picnic #foodstagram #deviledeggs #familyfavorite #tailgatesnacks #tailgate #lowcarb #easyrecipes #easypartyfood #coastalliving
4 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
7/9
You'll never be happy with any other Buffalo Wings again.  Sorry, not sorry.

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/buffalo-wings/

#footballfood #chickenwings #buffalowings
#foodstagram #foodporn #chickendinner #southerncooking #foodblogger #secfootball #hotsauce #deviledeggs #yum
You'll never be happy with any other Buffalo Wings again. Sorry, not sorry. Littlecoastalkitchen.com/buffalo-wings/ #footballfood #chickenwings #buffalowings #foodstagram #foodporn #chickendinner #southerncooking #foodblogger #secfootball #hotsauce #deviledeggs #yum
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
8/9
Ok, Arthur:  Here are the scallops you ordered!

Arthur's Bronzed Scallops with Lemon Butter Linguini
Littlecoastalkitchen.com/arthurs-bronzed-scallops/

#foodstagram #wildcaughtseafood #gulfcoastcooking #southerncooking #coastalliving #quickandeasymeals #quickandeasyrecipes #scallops #datenightdinner #pasta #yum
Ok, Arthur: Here are the scallops you ordered! Arthur's Bronzed Scallops with Lemon Butter Linguini Littlecoastalkitchen.com/arthurs-bronzed-scallops/ #foodstagram #wildcaughtseafood #gulfcoastcooking #southerncooking #coastalliving #quickandeasymeals #quickandeasyrecipes #scallops #datenightdinner #pasta #yum
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
9/9

Follow Us

2 Comments

  1. Julie Anne Cooper

    I’m sure I’ve had these before from you. Happy Valentine,s day.

    Reply
    • Malia

      I’m sure you have! Happy Valentine’s Day!

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More recipes in this category

Pimento Cheese Sausage Balls

Pimento Cheese Sausage Balls

When I told a friend I was going to test out a pimento cheese version of sausage balls, here’s what she said:  “Holy s%$#!  OMG!  Yes, please!” (We’re pretty enthusiastic about sausage balls around here.)   This recipe is exactly what it sounds like.  I added the...

Stuffed Acorn Squash

Stuffed Acorn Squash

Need a holiday side that seems fancy, yet is easy to make, and travels well?  And pairs beautifully with turkey OR ham? I know you’re planning now, and I’ve got you covered.  This is a job for Stuffed Acorn Squash.   I’ve served these delicious Stuffed Acorn...

Cranberry Pecan Cheese Ball

Cranberry Pecan Cheese Ball

I was reading an article recently about foods that have gone out of fashion.  Savory Jell-O salads, liver and onions, tv dinners, spray cheese, olive loaf--I can happily wave goodbye to all of these.  But some of the things on the list were just silly.   Who are...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This