Home » The Very Best Banana Pudding

The Very Best Banana Pudding

Over the years I’ve learned a few things about food and cooking:

–Respect your ingredients.

–Salt and pepper are ultimately the most important seasonings.

–Fresh is usually best, but not always.

–For Father’s Day dinner, Dads are interested in only two things: meat and banana pudding.

Okay, so the meat part I get. But I have to admit that I don’t really understand the relationship between guys and Banana Pudding. I’ve never found an answer, and believe me, I’ve tried. Best I can tell, guys all love, love, love it. Girls and women are not like this. I mean I like bananas and all, but WHAT IS IT WITH THE MENFOLK AND BANANA PUDDING?

I may never know. I do know that our shop hadn’t been open too long when a good friend came in and ordered Banana Pudding for 90 Presbyterians to be picked up in 3 days. Our philosophy was say yes first and ask questions later, so I readily agreed. I couldn’t imagine making Banana Pudding from scratch, including homemade meringue, for 90 people! I have never in my life made a decent meringue. That’s my Mom’s department. The second my friend was out the door, I fled to the kitchen and started Googling like a maniac.

It didn’t take long before I found a recipe called The Best Banana Pudding on Allrecipes. It had nearly a thousand 5 star reviews, and lo and behold, it was a no-cook recipe–no meringue at all. I won’t lie, I was skeptical. But all those reviews! And all those Presbyterians! And only two and a half days left!

I took a leap of faith, fiddled only slightly with the recipe, and forged ahead. We made A LOT of The Best Banana Pudding with a Couple of Tweaks and got it ready on time. Whew! And then something funny happened just days later. Presbyterians started coming in and looking around for Banana Pudding. We made more. It sold fast. We took special orders for big pans of Banana Pudding, they got picked up. Other customers came in and said they heard we had awesome Banana Pudding. We sold out and still made more. And then I made some for my Dad who adores Banana Pudding. Y’all, the man had probably never had no-cook Banana Pudding in his life. He called me on the phone and said it was really, really good. I breathed a sigh of relief and vowed then and there never to worry about from-scratch Banana Pudding again.

Please note that Father’s Day is this weekend, and if anyone knows why guys are so enamored with Banana Pudding, will you please clue me in? But first make the Dad in your life a batch of The Very Best Banana Pudding! A thousand reviewers–not to mention all those Presbyterians–can’t possibly be wrong. And if you need a suggestion for meat, THIS one is fantastic, easy, Dad-approved, and utterly foolproof. You’ll need some mashed potatoes. ♥️

The Very Best Banana Pudding

Ingredients

  • 2 3.4 oz. boxes cheesecake instant pudding mix
  • 2 cups cold milk
  • 1 can sweetened condensed milk
  • 1 t. vanilla extract
  • 1 12 oz. container frozen whipped topping, thawed
  • 1 16 oz. box vanilla wafers
  • 4 bananas, sliced
  • crushed vanilla wafers, cinnamon, allspice, or caramel sauce for sprinkling or drizzling on top, all optional

Instructions

  • in a large mixing bowl whisk together pudding mix and milk. Keep whisking for 2 minutes. The pudding will begin to thicken. Next, add the sweetened condensed milk and vanilla and whisk until well blended. Gently fold in the whipped topping.
  • Layer 1/2 the vanilla wafers, sliced bananas, and pudding mixture in a bowl or casserole dish, repeat. I like to put vanilla wafer crumbs on top. A drizzle of caramel sauce is also good. I also like a sprinkle of ground cinnamon and/or allspice. Use whatever you like, or no garnish at all.
  • Chill for a couple of hours before serving.

Newsletter Signup

Newsletter Signup

Sign up and be the first to receive our new recipes, class information and more! We promise not to share your information.

Instagram

Quick and easy dinner for spring: 

Apricot Pork Chops!

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/apricot-pork-chops/

#familydinner 
#familyfavorite 
#southerncooking
#foodstagram #porkchops 
#springtime #apricot #yum
Quick and easy dinner for spring: Apricot Pork Chops! Littlecoastalkitchen.com/apricot-pork-chops/ #familydinner #familyfavorite #southerncooking #foodstagram #porkchops #springtime #apricot #yum
5 days ago
View on Instagram |
1/9
I posted lovely, springy, Pasta al Limone on the blog a bit back, but I never got around to telling y'all about it.  So here it is now!  It's a good bet when you'd rather play outside on pretty evenings instead of cooking dinner. 

https://littlecoastalkitchen.com/pasta-al-limone/

#pasta #lemon #familydinner #familyfavorite #quickandeasymeals #quickandeasyrecipes #foodstagram #budgetmeals #kidfriendlyfood #italianfood  #yum!
I posted lovely, springy, Pasta al Limone on the blog a bit back, but I never got around to telling y'all about it. So here it is now! It's a good bet when you'd rather play outside on pretty evenings instead of cooking dinner. https://littlecoastalkitchen.com/pasta-al-limone/ #pasta #lemon #familydinner #familyfavorite #quickandeasymeals #quickandeasyrecipes #foodstagram #budgetmeals #kidfriendlyfood #italianfood #yum!
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
2/9
Cover easy, breezy, springtime dinner with this one-pan salmon wonder. 

Lemon and Honey Mustard Sheet Pan Salmon with Vegetables 

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/lemon-and-honey-mustard-sheet-pan-salmon/
Cover easy, breezy, springtime dinner with this one-pan salmon wonder. Lemon and Honey Mustard Sheet Pan Salmon with Vegetables Littlecoastalkitchen.com/lemon-and-honey-mustard-sheet-pan-salmon/
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
3/9
I have one more slot for the canning class on March 22nd, 10am.  Only $15! Who wants it?
I have one more slot for the canning class on March 22nd, 10am. Only $15! Who wants it?
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
4/9
It's salad season!  Kick it off with an easy and delicious Fried Chicken Cobb Salad!

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/fried-chicken-cobb-salad/

#southernfood #southerncooking
#foodstagram #salad #friedchicken #familyfriendly ##familydinner #yum
It's salad season! Kick it off with an easy and delicious Fried Chicken Cobb Salad! Littlecoastalkitchen.com/fried-chicken-cobb-salad/ #southernfood #southerncooking #foodstagram #salad #friedchicken #familyfriendly ##familydinner #yum
4 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
5/9
Water Bath Canning Class!

Learn the safe and easy USDA-approved water bath canning method!  Water bath canning is suitable for jams,  jellies, pickles, and preserves.  It requires no special equipment.  We'll make and can homemade strawberry preserves start to finish in class.  Class will run 2 to 3 hours.

When:  Saturday, March 22nd, 10 a.m.
Cost: $15 per person
Where:  Fairhope, venue TBA
Email malia@littlecoastalkitchen.com to reserve your spot!
Water Bath Canning Class!

Learn the safe and easy USDA-approved water bath canning method!  Water bath canning is suitable for jams,  jellies, pickles, and preserves.  It requires no special equipment.  We'll make and can homemade strawberry preserves start to finish in class.  Class will run 2 to 3 hours.

When:  Saturday, March 22nd, 10 a.m.
Cost: $15 per person
Where:  Fairhope, venue TBA
Email malia@littlecoastalkitchen.com to reserve your spot!
Water Bath Canning Class!

Learn the safe and easy USDA-approved water bath canning method!  Water bath canning is suitable for jams,  jellies, pickles, and preserves.  It requires no special equipment.  We'll make and can homemade strawberry preserves start to finish in class.  Class will run 2 to 3 hours.

When:  Saturday, March 22nd, 10 a.m.
Cost: $15 per person
Where:  Fairhope, venue TBA
Email malia@littlecoastalkitchen.com to reserve your spot!
Water Bath Canning Class! Learn the safe and easy USDA-approved water bath canning method! Water bath canning is suitable for jams, jellies, pickles, and preserves. It requires no special equipment. We'll make and can homemade strawberry preserves start to finish in class. Class will run 2 to 3 hours. When: Saturday, March 22nd, 10 a.m. Cost: $15 per person Where: Fairhope, venue TBA Email malia@littlecoastalkitchen.com to reserve your spot!
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
6/9
More pasta!  An oldie, but a goodie:

Seafood Stuffed Shells
Littlecoastalkitchen.com/seafood-stuffed-shells/

#foodstagram #southernfood #southerncooking
#pasta #freshseafood
#crab #shrimp #wildcaughtseafood #shrimprecipes #familyfriendly #familyfavorite #yum
More pasta! An oldie, but a goodie: Seafood Stuffed Shells Littlecoastalkitchen.com/seafood-stuffed-shells/ #foodstagram #southernfood #southerncooking #pasta #freshseafood #crab #shrimp #wildcaughtseafood #shrimprecipes #familyfriendly #familyfavorite #yum
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
7/9
Still trying to get into the Carnival spirit?  This will help:

Voodoo Pasta
Littlecoastalkitchen.com/voodoo-pasta/

#foodstagram #southerncooking #gulfcoastcooking #mardigras #pasta #sausage #shrimp #gulfseafood #yum
Still trying to get into the Carnival spirit? This will help: Voodoo Pasta Littlecoastalkitchen.com/voodoo-pasta/ #foodstagram #southerncooking #gulfcoastcooking #mardigras #pasta #sausage #shrimp #gulfseafood #yum
2 months ago
View on Instagram |
8/9
You know you want it.

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/bananas-foster-cake/

#southernfood #southerncooking #foodstagram #foodporn #creolefood #cake #mardigras #mobilemardigras #dessert #bananas #rum #yum
You know you want it. Littlecoastalkitchen.com/bananas-foster-cake/ #southernfood #southerncooking #foodstagram #foodporn #creolefood #cake #mardigras #mobilemardigras #dessert #bananas #rum #yum
2 months ago
View on Instagram |
9/9

Follow Us

2 Comments

  1. Eebie

    I’m totally laughing out loud! I just experienced the” guys love banana pudding epidemic!” Husband, son and grandad were happy as guys can be eating banana pudding and your creole pot roast! And they aren’t even Presbyterians!!

    Reply
    • Malia

      See?! LOL! Glad I could help!

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More recipes in this category

Apricot Pork Chops

Apricot Pork Chops

These delightfully tangy Apricot Pork Chops are simple enough and quick enough to become your new weeknight favorite.  The sauce ingredients are all pantry staples, with the possible exception of apricot preserves.  If you don’t have apricot preserves, pick up a jar...

Lemon and Honey Mustard Sheet Pan Salmon with Vegetables

Lemon and Honey Mustard Sheet Pan Salmon with Vegetables

Good news!  I’ve given up long-winded blog posts for Lent.     Hahahahaha!      I’m kidding, of course.  Lent or not, we all need a goodly number of easy and delicious seafood recipes, and I have a few words to say about that.  Let’s dive right in, shall we?...

Fried Chicken Cobb Salad

Fried Chicken Cobb Salad

When the weather turns toward spring, I start craving salad.  Especially meal-worthy salads.  You know, the ones with crunchy greens and enough meat and cheese that you don’t have to make anything else for dinner?   Well, this Fried Chicken Cobb Salad is a house...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This