Home » Perfect Blue Cheese Dressing

Perfect Blue Cheese Dressing

So what’s the deal with Blue Cheese Dressing? I wasn’t sure, either, so I Googled. Here’s the distilled version:

Best as culinary historians can tell, the earliest mention of a blue cheese salad dressing was in the Edgewater Beach Hotel Salad Book, published in 1928. The Edgewater resort was in Chicago on the Lake Michigan shore. Before that we don’t really know much. Roquefort cheese itself has been produced in what is now France since before the Roman occupation of Gaul. We know that because Pliny the Elder was very complimentary of it.

The name “Roquefort” became proprietary by the early 15th century, and after that–legally at least–other French blue-veined cheeses went by different names. Surely the famous Francophile Thomas Jefferson knew Roquefort and other French blue cheeses, and it’s hard to imagine he didn’t serve them at Monticello at some point. Jefferson entertained lavishly at home and regularly imported foods from France and Italy to serve to guests. In any case, blue cheese itself was well known all over the United States by the middle of the 19th century.

Historians are fairly certain that Blue Cheese (or Roquefort) Dressing didn’t evolve in France. When the French refer to salad dressing, they have always meant vinaigrette. England is also known for blue-veined cheeses made with cow’s milk, but, like the French, the English typically don’t eat thick salad dressings. We don’t know when salads and blue cheese got together prior to 1928, but we do know that American restaurants far and wide were serving wedge salads with Blue Cheese Dressing and bacon by the 1950s. We also know that when Buffalo wings made their debut in 1964 at the Anchor Bar in Buffalo, New York, Teressa Bellissimo famously served them with Blue Cheese Dressing for dunking.

Maybe the thick, creamy, tangy Blue Cheese Dressing we know and love is an American invention? No one knows for sure. Blue Cheese Dressing is ubiquitous in American steakhouses and on salad bars, and it’s iceberg lettuce’s very best friend. The Princess OG and I especially adore Blue Cheese Dressing, and we use it as both a dressing and a dip. I’ve been making the recipe below for years, I’ve served it loads of times, and it’s our favorite because it’s perfect. I have a quick word or two about ingredients. (Who would’ve guessed?!)

Blue cheese: I don’t use Maytag blue cheese, or Stilton, or any other premium blue cheese for dressing. Those are for special cheese plates and such. Right now I have Kraft™ Blue Cheese Crumbles in my cheese drawer, and I’ll be using that for dressing with impunity.

Buttermilk: Use cultured full-fat buttermilk for the best results.

You’ll never go back to the bottled stuff! (Sorry, not sorry!)

Cheers!

Blue Cheese Dressing

Ingredients

  • 4 oz. crumbled blue cheese, divided
  • 1 cup sour cream
  • ½ cup full-fat buttermilk
  • 1 t. Worcestershire sauce
  • 2 t. lemon juice
  • ¼ t. garlic powder
  • ½ t. each salt and pepper

Instructions

  • Add half the blue cheese to a mixing bowl, and mash with the back of a fork.
  • Add the sour cream, buttermilk, Worcestershire sauce, lemon juice, garlic powder, salt and pepper. Stir to combine.
  • Fold in the rest of the crumbled blue cheese. Refrigerate 2 hours to allow flavors to meld.

Newsletter Signup

Newsletter Signup

Sign up and be the first to receive our new recipes, class information and more! We promise not to share your information.

Instagram

Here's your new holiday side:  Stuffed Acorn Squash.

It's easy, delicious, and it travels well.

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/stuffed-acorn-squash/

#holidayfood #thanksgiving #southernfood
#foodstagram #southerncooking #familyfriendly
#easyrecipes #thanksgivingrecipes #stuffedvegetables #eatyourveggies #yum
Here's your new holiday side: Stuffed Acorn Squash. It's easy, delicious, and it travels well. Littlecoastalkitchen.com/stuffed-acorn-squash/ #holidayfood #thanksgiving #southernfood #foodstagram #southerncooking #familyfriendly #easyrecipes #thanksgivingrecipes #stuffedvegetables #eatyourveggies #yum
2 days ago
View on Instagram |
1/9
Yay!  Holiday party food is such a treat!  Today's installment is Cranberry Pecan Cheese Ball!

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/cranberry-pecan-cheese-ball/

#holidayfood #holidays #southerncooking #southernfood  #thanksgiving #partyfood #appetizers #cheese #cranberries #cranberry #pecans #familyfavorite #foodstagram #yum
Yay! Holiday party food is such a treat! Today's installment is Cranberry Pecan Cheese Ball! Littlecoastalkitchen.com/cranberry-pecan-cheese-ball/ #holidayfood #holidays #southerncooking #southernfood #thanksgiving #partyfood #appetizers #cheese #cranberries #cranberry #pecans #familyfavorite #foodstagram #yum
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
2/9
UPDATE:  Lazy Chef's Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen is full.  HOWEVER, if we can fill another class, I'll add one!  I need 8 attendees for the class to fill.  I'm looking at the calendar now---
UPDATE: Lazy Chef's Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen is full. HOWEVER, if we can fill another class, I'll add one! I need 8 attendees for the class to fill. I'm looking at the calendar now---
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
3/9
Join us for our annual Lazy Chef's Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen 2024! I'll be making brand new, easy, inexpensive gifts this year, no cooking skills required. Class is Saturday, Dec. 7th, 10am. Email me to register: malia@littlecoastalkitchen.com. Class is $40, and it's always fun!
Join us for our annual Lazy Chef's Holiday Gifts from the Kitchen 2024! I'll be making brand new, easy, inexpensive gifts this year, no cooking skills required. Class is Saturday, Dec. 7th, 10am. Email me to register: malia@littlecoastalkitchen.com. Class is $40, and it's always fun!
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
4/9
It's TexMex Tuesday,  y'all.  What are you having for dinner?  Weeknight Chicken Carnitas!

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/weeknight-chicken-carnitas/
It's TexMex Tuesday, y'all. What are you having for dinner? Weeknight Chicken Carnitas! Littlecoastalkitchen.com/weeknight-chicken-carnitas/
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
5/9
It's available!  My new cookbook, Soups and Sides, is up on Amazon, in both hardback and paperback.  Enjoy!

#cookbooks #christmaspresents #soup
#soupseason #familyfriendly #familyfriendly #homecooking #recipes #yum
It's available! My new cookbook, Soups and Sides, is up on Amazon, in both hardback and paperback. Enjoy! #cookbooks #christmaspresents #soup #soupseason #familyfriendly #familyfriendly #homecooking #recipes #yum
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
6/9
By request.  Deviled Eggs!

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/deviled-eggs/

#southerncooking #picnic #foodstagram #deviledeggs #familyfavorite #tailgatesnacks #tailgate #lowcarb #easyrecipes #easypartyfood #coastalliving
By request. Deviled Eggs! Littlecoastalkitchen.com/deviled-eggs/ #southerncooking #picnic #foodstagram #deviledeggs #familyfavorite #tailgatesnacks #tailgate #lowcarb #easyrecipes #easypartyfood #coastalliving
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
7/9
You'll never be happy with any other Buffalo Wings again.  Sorry, not sorry.

Littlecoastalkitchen.com/buffalo-wings/

#footballfood #chickenwings #buffalowings
#foodstagram #foodporn #chickendinner #southerncooking #foodblogger #secfootball #hotsauce #deviledeggs #yum
You'll never be happy with any other Buffalo Wings again. Sorry, not sorry. Littlecoastalkitchen.com/buffalo-wings/ #footballfood #chickenwings #buffalowings #foodstagram #foodporn #chickendinner #southerncooking #foodblogger #secfootball #hotsauce #deviledeggs #yum
4 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
8/9
Ok, Arthur:  Here are the scallops you ordered!

Arthur's Bronzed Scallops with Lemon Butter Linguini
Littlecoastalkitchen.com/arthurs-bronzed-scallops/

#foodstagram #wildcaughtseafood #gulfcoastcooking #southerncooking #coastalliving #quickandeasymeals #quickandeasyrecipes #scallops #datenightdinner #pasta #yum
Ok, Arthur: Here are the scallops you ordered! Arthur's Bronzed Scallops with Lemon Butter Linguini Littlecoastalkitchen.com/arthurs-bronzed-scallops/ #foodstagram #wildcaughtseafood #gulfcoastcooking #southerncooking #coastalliving #quickandeasymeals #quickandeasyrecipes #scallops #datenightdinner #pasta #yum
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
9/9

Follow Us

7 Comments

  1. Mary Margaret

    How long does this keep?

    Reply
    • Malia

      If everything is fresh when you make it, it should be good for a week to 10 days.

      Reply
  2. Leslie Anne Tarabella

    I just printed this to stick in my “favorites” cookbook. Whenever I’ve tried to make Blue Cheese Dressing, it always turned out to thin – this looks like the answer! Thanks.

    Reply
    • Malia

      You can always adjust the sour cream and buttermilk if you need to.

      Reply
  3. Mother

    I am so sorry you never liked mayonnaise. I use a really good mayonnaise, Sir Kensington’s Classic Mayonnaise, instead of sour cream or sometimes just a spoonful or two of sour cream, then some mayonnaise in my Blue Cheese Dressing. I find the flavor better with wings and carrots and celery. Yum!!
    Signed… Your Mother!!!!

    Reply
    • Malia

      LOL! Do you use buttermilk or cream, or anything to thin it down a bit? (Y’all pay attention. My mom is giving us a recipe!)

      Reply
      • Mother

        Yes i use buttermilk , mayonnaise and maybe a small spoonful or two of sour cream, but not always. I use the other listed ingredients and a dash of onion powder and dried parsley.

        Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Buffalo Wings - Little Coastal Kitchen - […] a plate of Buffalo wings with Perfect Blue Cheese Dressing, celery, carrots, and deviled eggs is fine dining any…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More recipes in this category

Stuffed Acorn Squash

Stuffed Acorn Squash

Need a holiday side that seems fancy, yet is easy to make, and travels well?  And pairs beautifully with turkey OR ham? I know you’re planning now, and I’ve got you covered.  This is a job for Stuffed Acorn Squash.   I’ve served these delicious Stuffed Acorn...

Cranberry Pecan Cheese Ball

Cranberry Pecan Cheese Ball

I was reading an article recently about foods that have gone out of fashion.  Savory Jell-O salads, liver and onions, tv dinners, spray cheese, olive loaf--I can happily wave goodbye to all of these.  But some of the things on the list were just silly.   Who are...

Weeknight Chicken Carnitas

Weeknight Chicken Carnitas

If you’ve ever had Mexican carnitas you already know they’re delicious. The name “carnitas” means “little meats”.  Traditionally, carnitas are made by slowly braising a pork shoulder in a highly seasoned broth, then shredding the meat, and frying it in its own fat...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This